Overview
Carbon dioxide is the product of complete oxidation. Even organisms absolutely dependent on oxygen cannot live more than one generation without adequate carbon dioxide. Almost everything in physiology comes back to CO2. When the cell is producing enough CO2, lactic acid is suppressed, proteins are stabilized, calcium is moved out of cells, bones calcify properly, inflammation is reduced, nerves rest, and oxygen is delivered to tissues in the right way. When CO2 falls (eg. from hypothyroidism, hyperventilation, aerobic exercise, estrogen, polyunsaturated fats, or aging), the cell slips back toward lactic acid metabolism and the whole inflammatory, degenerative cascade starts.
Key Points
-
CO2 directly suppresses lactic acid production. Lactic acid is the signature of the low-energy, pre-oxidative state that Warburg, Koch, and Szent-Györgyi all identified with cancer. Carbon dioxide shuts off lactic acid production in several ways at once, including combining with ammonia (which otherwise accelerates lactate formation) and replenishing the Krebs cycle. Breathing in a bag for a minute or so several times a day will measurably lower serum lactic acid.
-
Carbon dioxide is a powerful antioxidant by electron-retraction. It is a Lewis acid, meaning it doesn't donate protons, but its two double-bonded oxygens on one carbon make it a strong electron binder. When it sits down on a protein, it pulls the electrons toward itself and stabilizes the whole molecule. In horse studies where blood CO2 was raised by around 3x the normal range (from 30 to 100), no free radicals were detectable in the bloodstream at all.
-
CO2 is the signal that makes oxygen actually usable at the tissue level. The Haldane-Bohr effect describes how carbon dioxide sticking to hemoglobin knocks oxygen loose where it is needed in the capillaries. The same effect generally applies to proteins, too. In the heart, increasing blood CO2 increases actual oxygen delivery, and it directs oxygen to the right places rather than letting it stick where it shouldn't and attack polyunsaturated fats. Carbogen, a mixture of roughly 5 to 7 percent CO2 with oxygen, has been used since the 1930s for stroke, resuscitation, and altitude sickness, but is still almost absent from modern hospitals.
-
CO2 protects proteins from glycation and modification. Any amino group in the body, whether on DNA, enzymes, or hormone receptors, is a binding site for carbon dioxide. When CO2 saturates those sites, glycation end products and free-radical fatty acid fragments cannot attach. About 95 percent of the glycated proteins that accumulate in diabetes and aging actually come from fatty acid breakdown, not sugar. Insulin is a different hormone in the presence of CO2 than in its absence, and the same is true of growth hormone and every peptide hormone.
-
High altitude produces the lactate paradox and lower rates of degenerative disease. At high altitude the lower oxygen pressure means hemoglobin retains a higher residual CO2, and the tissues adapt by producing more mitochondria. A person adapted to altitude can work full force without generating the excess lactic acid they would at sea level.
-
Thyroid, sugar, and avoiding PUFA are the dietary basis for CO2 production. Thyroid hormone is what lets the mitochondria fully oxidize fuel into CO2 rather than leaving it stuck at lactate. Oxidizing glucose produces much more CO2 per unit of oxygen than oxidizing fat, and fructose catalyzes the more energetic burning of glucose. Polyunsaturated fats directly interfere with the enzymes that send electrons to oxygen, and within minutes of an intravenous fat infusion, the ability to use glucose is suppressed.
-
Bag breathing, baking soda, carbonated springs, and dry CO2 baths all raise body CO2. Re-breathing into a paper bag for one to two minutes trains the nerves to tolerate higher CO2 and can drop elevated blood pressure by 30 points over a day or two. A tablespoon of baking soda at the start of an endurance race improves performance; the sodium holds the bicarbonate in solution, and the body pulls the bicarbonate in and converts it to intracellular CO2. Sitting with the legs or whole body in a plastic bag filled from a CO2 tank makes the skin pink and warm within minutes as skin blood vessels relax. Carbonated mineral springs produce the same effect, and the body absorbs CO2 from the water up the gradient because it has such an affinity for it.
-
CO2 stabilizes calcium metabolism and builds bone. In rats on a vitamin D deficient diet, those fed sucrose instead of starch developed strong calcified bones anyway, because the higher metabolic rate and CO2 production calcified the skeleton. Parathyroid hormone dissolves bone in culture by shifting the cell toward lactic acid, but raising CO2 reverses that and begins laying down calcium carbonate crystals. This is why filling a bag with CO2 and sealing it around a broken limb is used to accelerate bone healing.
-
CO2 extends slow-wave sleep and calms the nervous system. Experiments with people sleeping in atmospheres of 0.5 to 1.5 percent CO2, compared to the normal 400 parts per million, show a dramatic increase in deep slow-wave regenerative sleep. Low-thyroid people hyperventilate chemically even at sea level, which is why they develop altitude-sickness insomnia when they go to higher altitudes. When CO2 is adequate, platelets retain their histamine and serotonin rather than leaking them into the blood vessels, blood vessels stop leaking water, and the whole inflammatory cascade is quieted.
-
CO2 is the body's primary endogenous vasodilator and keeps blood vessels supple. Its mechanical role is to let blood vessels expand on demand during exertion or stress so the heart is not forced to push against stiff pipes. With chronic treatment, CO2 has been shown to restore expandability even in heavily calcified vessels, which means soft tissue calcification and some signs of aging can actually be reversed if the treatment continues long enough.
-
When CO2 falls, inducible nitric oxide synthase takes over as an emergency vasodilator, and this is harmful. Low CO2 automatically triggers iNOS, spilling nitric oxide systemically. Nitric oxide forms a covalent bond with cytochrome c-oxidase at complex four of the electron transport chain, which irreversibly suffocates oxidative phosphorylation until new enzyme is produced. Only red light, methylene blue, magnesium, and CO2 itself can break that bond.
-
CO2 is anti-estrogen, anti-serotonin, and anti-histamine. Producing sufficient CO2 has an anti-aromatase effect, so less estrogen is synthesised. It increases the uptake of serotonin into the platelets, which lowers the extracellular serotonin that causes inflammation, and it increases the deactivation of histamine. Exogenous CO2 reproduces the effects of the selective serotonin reuptake enhancer tianeptine, which is a powerful antidepressant in its own right.
-
CO2 is therapeutic for cancer because it is a Lewis acid that drops cellular pH. Cancer cells are highly alkaline, overproducing lactate and absorbing water. The Latin word for tumor means swelling. Increasing CO2 around a surface tumor, or using carbonic anhydrase inhibitors like acetazolamide or thiamine to slow CO2's breakdown, acidifies the cell, allows apoptosis to occur, and can reduce tumor swelling. Ray Peat's explanation for acetazolamide's remarkable preclinical anti-cancer effects across multiple tumor types was simply that it raises intracellular CO2 and therefore acidity.
Notable Quotes
"Every cell or tissue that you look at, it's protected if you restore the proper amount of carbon dioxide."
[Ray Peat — KMUD: Water Retention and Salt]
"They call it oxygen because it means acid former. And the acid that it makes is carbon dioxide."
[Ray Peat — KMUD: Water Retention and Salt]
"Everything in your body is different when it's well saturated with CO2. You can't suffer the side effects of diabetes, for example, if your proteins are protected."
[Ray Peat — KMUD: Altitude]
"Lactic acid down, carbon dioxide up, are the most powerful indicators of good health in one life."
[Ray Peat — Jodelle Fitzwater Q&A: Weight Loss, Stretch Marks, Hydrogen, Negative Ions]
"It turns out that carbon dioxide, even though medically it's viewed as mostly a waste product of respiration, it's actually the thing that protects us from oxygen's well-known toxicity."
[Georgi Dinkov — The Underappreciated Role of Carbon Dioxide in Health]
"Almost everything that you do metabolically in terms of health depends on the production of CO2. It's not a waste product."
[Georgi Dinkov — The Underappreciated Role of Carbon Dioxide in Health]
"Every condition you can think of, both physiological and mental, can be remediated, and in many cases cured, by an increasing endogenous CO2 production, decreasing its degradation, which is what the carbonic anhydrase inhibitors do."
[Georgi Dinkov — The Underappreciated Role of Carbon Dioxide in Health]
"How much carbon dioxide you exhale is probably the cardinal measurement of health anything going on in your body really and anything that decreases any any sign of decrease of carbon dioxide indicates metabolism is not working."
[Georgi Dinkov — Hormones, Losing Fat and Building Muscle]
"Carbon dioxide is your main and preferred vasodilator. If you don't have it for whatever reason, which means metabolism is not working well, the emergency one that immediately activates just the deficiency of carbon dioxide is a signal for the activation of something called inducible nitric oxide synthase."
[Georgi Dinkov — Crucial Facts About Your Metabolism, Part 2]
Important Things To Consider
Aerobic exercise lowers CO2 and drives the stress system. Running, jogging, and cycling blow off large amounts of CO2, increase adrenaline, raise cortisol, lower testosterone, and produce lactic acid that persists for days in well-trained athletes. Mild muscle-building activity, concentric contraction against resistance, and brief bursts followed by recovery are preferable. Eccentric exercise, such as walking downhill or muscle lengthening under load, damages mitochondria.
Asthma is the one condition that worsens at high altitude. While cancer, heart disease, and dementia mortality all fall as altitude rises, people with weakened lungs can suffer at elevation.
Breath-holding time should be matched to metabolic rate. Holding the breath raises CO2, but a person with high thyroid function consumes oxygen so quickly that they may become unconscious after a minute, whereas a hypothyroid person can go four times as long.
Smoking raises CO2 but raises carbon monoxide far more. Carbon monoxide is produced under stress and lowers the ability to use oxygen and to produce CO2. It causes clots in the brain, leaky blood vessels, and many of the same processes seen in multiple sclerosis and atherosclerosis. It is not a useful route to raising CO2.
Carbogen is almost unavailable in modern hospitals. Only two or three hospitals out of thousands surveyed had carbogen on hand. Mainstream medicine still follows a 1955 UK committee declaration that keeping CO2 in the blood is irrational, and doctors are trained to reduce rather than support it.
Do not put a CO2-filled bag above the neck. For treating legs, arms, or the body below the shoulders, a plastic bag filled from a CO2 cylinder works well. Breathing pure CO2 is not the goal; the skin absorbs it directly.
Estrogen makes nerves overreactive to CO2 and drives hyperventilation. Under excess estrogen everyone tends to hyperventilate and blow out CO2, sometimes to the point of alkalosis. Progesterone, thyroid, and pregnenolone all work in the opposite direction and train the nervous system to tolerate and retain CO2.
Bicarbonate on a standard blood panel is a decent surrogate for CO2 but not perfect. The true measure is partial CO2 pressure via an arterial catheter. Bicarbonate can be elevated for the wrong reasons, buffering acidity from elsewhere, rather than because CO2 is genuinely high. A practical range is 22 to 32, with anything under 25 suggesting overexertion, hyperventilation, or a stressed fasted state. A capnometer that measures exhaled CO2 is more direct; above 35 suggests healthy metabolism, with one exception below.
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease causes high CO2 for the wrong reason. In COPD, elevated CO2 is a sign of failed gas exchange, not robust metabolism, so high readings on a capnometer in that context do not indicate health.
Osteopetrosis is a genetic condition where too much CO2 is a problem. People with marble bone disease lack carbonic anhydrase and retain very high CO2, which gives them extraordinarily tough bones but can fuse the spine, compress the brainstem, and kill them. This is an extremely rare condition.
Exogenous CO2 inhalation triggers a panic-like strangulation reaction as CO2 builds in a closed container. This is actually a sign of healthy metabolism: the faster the panic sets in when breathing into a paper bag, the more CO2 the body is producing. A person in a very bad metabolic state can breathe in and out of the same bag for 10 minutes and feel nothing because they are producing almost no CO2. The sensation is uncomfortable but it is the body responding normally.
Acetazolamide and thiamine raise CO2. Acetazolamide, also known as Diamox, is a carbonic anhydrase inhibitor and a safe diuretic that does not deplete sodium, potassium, or magnesium, unlike mainstream diuretics. It is used clinically for intracranial pressure. Thiamine, vitamin B1, was recently discovered to be as potent as acetazolamide as a carbonic anhydrase inhibitor. A combination of acetazolamide and thiamine achieved 70 percent cure rates for severe mental illness cases that were considered terminal in the mid-20th century.
Pulse oximeter readings of 100 percent are not necessarily good. A corpse reads 100 percent saturation because the oxygen is bound to hemoglobin and never dissociates. In a healthy metabolically active person, readings between 92 and 94 are probably ideal.
Breathing pure oxygen in hospital settings is actively dangerous. People delivered too much oxygen too quickly after shock or an ischemic event often die from the cytokine storm and reactive oxygen species that follow. A carbogen mix of oxygen and CO2 is safer but more expensive and most hospitals do not stock it. This is the same reason high-altitude climbers mix gases rather than breathing pure oxygen.